In Hollow Knight and Silksong, some characters become enormous over time – especially queens. Players often wonder why these bugs grow far beyond the size of normal insects. While the game does not give a single direct explanation, the community has formed several consistent theories based on lore, biology, and dialogue.
This guide breaks down the key ideas behind why queen characters become giant, including insights from Karmelita, the Skarr tribe, and comparisons to queens in Hollow Knight.
1. Queens Grow Because They Bear Massive Numbers of Children
In the world of Hollow Knight, queens are not symbolic – they are biological.
- Queens are responsible for producing thousands of offspring.
- Constant reproduction reshapes their bodies, causing unnatural growth.
- This mirrors real-world social insects like ants and bees.
Characters such as Vespa (Hive Queen), White Lady, and the giant queens seen in Silksong demonstrate this pattern. Their size reflects lifetimes dedicated to creating and nurturing their species.
2. Karmelita and the Skarr: Is She Literally Their Mother?
Players debate whether Karmelita is the biological mother of all Skarr or more of a unifying leader. Several clues exist:
Supporting the “Biological Mother” Theory:
- She repeatedly refers to the Skarr as “my children.”
- Her lines in fights and memories use maternal language consistently.
- Team Cherry previously established Vespa as the literal mother of her hive, suggesting they follow insect-world logic.
Supporting the “Leader, Not Mother” Theory:
- Lore states she “united all Skarr” – meaning they existed before her rule.
- Her motherhood theme may be symbolic, tied to leadership or culture rather than birth.
Most likely interpretation:
Karmelita probably did produce some of the Skarr, but not all of them. She became a queen-like figure whose motherhood is both literal and symbolic, shaping the tribe through birth and unity.
3. Motherhood as a Core Theme in Silksong
Silksong heavily emphasizes themes of:
- motherhood and care,
- leadership through family,
- bodies shaped by responsibility,
- the tragedy of queens decaying after a lifetime of service.
Many characters in the game refer to others as “my children,” even without giving birth. This reflects a cultural pattern: motherhood as identity, not just biology.
4. Why Are Characters Like the White Lady So Huge?
The White Lady stands apart because she is tree-like (or possibly fungal). Her massive size comes from:
- being rooted in place for years,
- continually growing without pruning,
- withdrawing from her duties, letting her body expand unchecked,
- possibly returning to a “wild” natural state.
Her growth is not maternal in the biological sense – it’s botanical.
5. “Insect Queens Are Big” – The Simplified Explanation
Another widely accepted idea:
The longer a queen serves as a queen, the larger she naturally becomes.
Herrah the Beast is a clear example. While not as large as some Silksong queens, she is still much bigger than normal weavers because of her queen status and duty.
Queenhood shapes the body.
6. The Tragedy of Karmelita
Players often express sadness at Karmelita’s fate. She is the perfect example of the Silksong approach to queens:
- once powerful, agile, and full of song,
- now decaying and frozen in a body too heavy to move,
- still trying to sing for her children as they fall into madness,
- watching helplessly as her tribe destroys itself.
Seeing a queen at her peak and then witnessing her decline is one of the emotional highlights of both games.
Final Thoughts
Giant queens in Silksong and Hollow Knight are not just design choices. They reflect deep world-building themes:
- Reproduction transforms bodies.
- Leadership becomes motherhood.
- Queenhood brings both power and decay.
- The world is shaped by the sacrifices of its mothers.
The result is a universe where size is not just physical – it symbolizes legacy, burden, and the weight of protecting a species.
Why queens in Silksong grow so large: Covers motherhood, biology, Karmelita’s lore, and how queenhood shapes bug size in the Hollow Knight world.